Much Ado Essay (and Updates)

Over the next few days, we will be writing our Much Ado essays. Now that you have a good draft of your essay question completed, you’ll begin the task of sitting down to answer it.

To view all submitted essay questions, click here.

If you are struggling with formulating an essay question, try this one: What can  Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing teach today’s readers about X? (where X might equal any of the following: gender differences, the importance of honor, the effects of deception, etc.).

To answer your question, you’ll write a 5-part essay (not a 5-paragraph essay). To learn more about the 5-part essay, read a sample that I wrote by clicking here (Period 3: you may find it helpful to print out a copy to annotate).

As you read, consider what goes in each part; in other words, what is the purpose of each part of the essay?

Note: Your introduction doens’t need to be as long as the sample, nor does it have to be a personal anecdote like mine. Other types of intros are possible (see box in the link).

Now, review the key differences between a traditional 5-paragraph essay and a 5-part essay (in the real world, it’s called a Classical arrangement, which is a tried-and-true form that was first established by the ancient Greeks and that we still use and find in much of professional writing today). Click here to see an outline of the 5-PART essay and the key differences between the two forms.  

NOTE: This weekend, I will be writing up more examples of the 5-part essay. A link will be posted here shortly, so come back to check it out. Click here for two more sample outlines of 5-part essays using To Kill a Mockingbird and Romeo and Juliet. In particular, note the different types of introductions and thesis statements.

Now go back to the sample essay(s) I wrote and note the following:

  • How does the introduction transition to the text?
  • Where is the thesis statement? What is in the thesis statement?
  • How are the quotations from the book integrated and cited?

As you can tell, the 5-part essay is much more flexible. At the same time, it’s also more logical. You start broad from either the Reader circle or the World circle and then connect to a R-T or R-W or even an R-T-W question. Then you answer that question by looking at examples in the text from the beginning, middle, and end (your body paragraphs can follow this organization; that’s what I did in my sample essay). Before you conclude, you consider other points of view (this is the Refutation part) and then conclude with a “final thesis.”

One thing you might consider doing is posing a question in the Introduction or Narration (for example: What would drive Claudio to reject, and moreover, to publicly shame Hero in the way that he did?). Then you use the Confirmation body paragraphs to answer that question (for example: by examining Hero and Claudio’s relationship as it unfolds chronologically in the play). In the Refutation, you consider other possible answers to the question (for example:  other theories as to why Claudio  did what he did, like maybe he was primarily acting out of his own feelings of betrayal) and then in the Conclusion, you argue that X reason is the  best answer to that question (for example: Because of the  differing expectations for men and women in society at the time, Claudio’s actions are deemed acceptable).


Next week’s schedule:

MONDAY: Much Ado quiz (for periods 5 and 6) and Vocab Quiz (all periods, up to word #40), then either IR or continue working on  your essay (BYOD, or laptops available). One IR reflection is due. Note: After Monday, we will pause our IR reading to make space/time for reading Lord of the Flies, which will be distributed in class this week.

TUESDAY: Work on essay in class (BYOD, or laptops available). Continue working on essay at home.

WEDNESDAY: Background on LOTF.  Books distributed. Begin reading in class and taking sticky notes; Work on essay at home.

THURSDAY: Read LOTF in class, take sticky notes. Work on essay at home.

FRIDAY: First draft of essay due. Read LOTF in class/take sticky notes and at home. No AoW due.

NEXT WEEK: Read LOTF in class/take sticky notes. Finish book by the Monday, 1/4. Revise essay over break; final copy due Tuesday, 1/5 Thursday, 1/7.

Comments/questions:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s